Public AI or private AI? Why some things should stay local
Public AI tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Copilot are genuinely useful, and we use them too. The real question for a business is not whether to use AI, but where your data goes when you do.
What happens when you paste data into a public AI tool
When someone types a prompt or uploads a file to a public AI service, that content is processed on the provider's servers, outside your control. Depending on the plan and settings, it may be stored, reviewed for abuse monitoring or, on some consumer plans, used to improve future models. Business and enterprise plans usually offer stronger protections, but terms differ between providers and can change over time.
The bigger risk is often "shadow AI": staff using personal accounts to get their work done faster, pasting in source code, contracts or customer details without realising where that information ends up.
What should stay local
- Source code and secrets. Proprietary code, algorithms, API keys and credentials.
- Personal and customer data. Anything covered by GDPR, from CRM records to KYC documents.
- Commercially sensitive documents. Contracts, financials, board papers, M&A and legal material.
- Security information. Network diagrams, logs, vulnerability reports and incident details.
- Regulated data. Information covered by financial services, iGaming or healthcare rules.
Why private, self-hosted AI makes sense for this work
- Your data stays yours. Prompts, documents and outputs never leave infrastructure you control, in Malta, the EU or your own building.
- Easier compliance. Keeping processing in a known location simplifies GDPR, NIS2, DORA and sector obligations.
- No surprises. You are not exposed to a provider changing its terms, retention policy or pricing.
- Built around you. Private models can be connected to your internal systems and tuned on your own data.
- Predictable costs. For heavy, steady use, owning or renting dedicated capacity can be more predictable than paying per request.
The honest trade-offs
Private AI is not free of compromises. The very largest frontier models are only available as public services, and running your own models means investing in hardware or dedicated hosting. But open-weight models have closed much of the gap for everyday work such as coding assistance, summarisation and answering questions over your own documents, and the hardware to run them has become far more accessible.
The best answer is usually both
Use public AI for general, non-sensitive work where its scale is an advantage. Use private AI for anything confidential, regulated or core to your competitive edge. Put a clear policy in place so your people know which is which. We help businesses design exactly this kind of hybrid setup, from the policy through to the hardware.
